Mazda CX-5 vs Subaru Forester: Which SUV Should I Choose?

Car Buying Advice
1

Looking to buy a new SUV and I’m torn between the Mazda CX-5 and the Subaru Forester. I’m reaching out to see if anyone here has had experiences with either vehicle and can share insights to help me make my decision.

What I’m Considering:

  • Performance: How do they compare in terms of handling and engine power?
  • Comfort: Which one offers a better ride experience and interior space?
  • Technology: Are there any standout features in either that you’ve appreciated?
  • Cost-Effectiveness: What about maintenance costs and fuel efficiency?

Personal Usage:

I’ll mostly be using it for everyday commuting, the occasional road trip, and maybe some mild off-roading on weekends.

Any thoughts on reliability and overall satisfaction would be super helpful. If you have links to reviews or comparisons, I’d appreciate those too! Thanks in advance for your input!

2

I’ve driven both the Mazda CX-5 and Subaru Forester, and from my experience, the CX-5 has a sportier feel. Its turbo engine offers quicker acceleration compared to the Forester’s more modest power train.

3

That’s a great point! The CX-5 is definitely fun to drive, especially in tight corners. But can the Forester match that with its handling?

4

The Forester has excellent visibility and is super stable on rough terrain, which I love. Its all-wheel drive capabilities are fantastic for winter driving. How does the CX-5 handle in snow?

5

In my experience, the CX-5 handles pretty well in snow, especially with the AWD system. It’s more about driver input, but the grip is good!

6

Fuel efficiency is another key difference! The Forester generally gives better MPG numbers, especially on highway driving. Anyone notice a significant difference in day-to-day usage?

7

Absolutely! I’ve found that the Forester does help save on gas for longer trips. But does the CX-5 suffer too much with its fuel economy?

8

Performance-wise, the CX-5 feels more like a luxury SUV compared to the Forester. The interior and ride quality just seem more upscale. Anyone agree?

9

I agree, the CX-5 feels more premium inside, but some may prefer the utilitarian feel of the Forester’s interior.

7 Likes
10

For me, it’s about how you’ll use the vehicle. If you’re more into off-roading or need extra cargo space, the Forester is the winner there.

11

That’s a solid point! I think it really comes down to lifestyle and what fits your needs better.

12

I’m curious about the overall long-term reliability of these vehicles. Have any of you faced maintenance issues with either the CX-5 or Forester?

2 Likes
13

So far, my CX-5 has been reliable with minimal issues. The Forester is generally rated high on reliability, though.

14

I’ll throw in a humor element: If you want to feel like you’re driving a sports car without actually buying one, go for the CX-5! Just don’t forget, it’s still a family SUV!

15

Haha, that’s one way to put it! But while the CX-5 feels sporty, can it really handle rough weather like the Forester?

6 Likes
16

I think both SUVs have their merits. It’s about what you prioritize—performance with CX-5 or versatility with Forester. Life’s too short to stress over it too much!

17

I’m also looking into the CX-5 and Forester! I’ve read the CX-5 consistently has high safety ratings, especially with the IIHS. Their advanced driver assistance features are impressive too.

18

Yes, the IIHS ratings are important. The Forester also received good ratings, but I feel it’s more about personal preference in terms of looks and features.

8 Likes
19

When considering long-term reliability, Subaru has a strong reputation. My Forester has been going strong for over five years without major issues.

1 Like
20

That’s a great point, but I think the CX-5 is catching up in reliability ratings. There have been fewer complaints in recent years.