Toyota Highlander vs. 4Runner: Which SUV is Right for Me?

Car Buying Advice
1

I’m in the market for a new SUV and I’m torn between the Toyota Highlander and the Toyota 4Runner. I’ve done some reading, but I want to hear from others who may have experience with these models.

Performance Comparison

  • Highlander: Known for its smooth ride and better fuel efficiency. I’ve heard it handles well in city driving and offers decent power for highway merging.
  • 4Runner: More rugged and capable off-road, but I worry about the gas mileage. Is it really as tough as they say?

Interior and Features

  • Highlander: It seems to have a more upscale interior with more tech features like Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. How does it hold up over time?
  • 4Runner: I appreciate its durability and practicality, but is the interior dated?

Pricing and Value

I also need to consider the budget. The Highlander appears to be a bit more affordable upfront, but does that come with fewer long-term savings? How do the maintenance costs compare?

Overall Suitability

Finally, which one fits better for a family with kids and occasional outdoor adventures? Any advice, personal experiences, or tips would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks for your help!

2 Likes
2

I’m thinking about the Highlander vs. 4Runner too! The Highlander feels more like a family SUV, while the 4Runner is the go-to for off-roading. It really depends on your needs!

3

That’s a good point! The Highlander definitely has a smoother ride and better handling on roads compared to the 4Runner. But for towing, the 4Runner’s got it beat.

4

I agree with both of you! The 4Runner is really built for rugged terrain. It has exceptional off-road capabilities with features like Multi-Terrain Select and Crawl Control.

5

Exactly! If you’re hitting trails often, the 4Runner is the clear winner. But for day-to-day driving, the Highlander is more practical.

6

Doesn’t the Highlander have better fuel efficiency too? I think that might be a big factor if you’re commuting more than off-roading.

3 Likes
7

Absolutely! The Highlander’s hybrid version is great for saving on gas without sacrificing space. It’s perfect for families.

8

What about towing capacity? I heard the 4Runner can tow over 5,000 lbs, but I’m not sure about the Highlander.

9

The Highlander can tow around 5,000 lbs too if you get the right configuration. It really comes down to how often you plan to tow heavy loads.

10

I think both have solid engine options, but the V6 in the 4Runner offers more raw power for off-road hikes. Anyone here ever tested both?

11

I’ve driven both, and the 4Runner definitely feels more rugged. You feel more connected to the road or the trail in the 4Runner, while the Highlander feels cushier.

12

It sounds like the Highlander is the better choice for city driving, while the 4Runner rules off-road. What if someone wants a bit of both?

13

If someone wants both, I’d recommend checking out the Toyota RAV4. It offers versatility with a nice balance of performance and comfort for both city and off-road!

14

That could be a good compromise! But for a larger option, maybe consider the Highlander for family trips and the 4Runner for weekend adventures.

2 Likes
15

Looking at these comments, it’s clear there are trade-offs. Highlander’s comfort or 4Runner’s toughness… such a tough choice, right!

16

And who doesn’t want a little of both worlds? I feel like asking ourselves, ‘what will I actually use it for?’ can really help decide!

17

I chuckle at myself for even considering the Highlander for off-roading! I’d just end up stuck in a mud pit, haha.

18

I’ve been researching both SUVs and found that the Highlander has more interior space, especially in the third row. It might be better for families needing that extra room.

2 Likes
19

That’s a good point! Although, if you’re looking for off-road capability, the 4Runner is unbeatable! I love its rugged design.

20

The Highlander definitely focuses on passenger comfort. I sat in one recently, and the seats felt fantastic for long drives!

4 Likes